Tree Establishment: Helping Urban Trees Thrive
Since our inception in 1993, Trees for Cities has planted nearly 2 million trees in 100 urban areas across the UK and overseas. But how well have our trees established and do they continue to thrive? We are proud to showcase our efforts in establishing, maintaining and caring for our trees over the last 33 years.
Why is tree establishment important?
There is simply no point in planting trees unless they establish and thrive, so Trees for Cities places great emphasis on maintaining our newly planted trees.
Mature trees bring multiple and wide-ranging benefits to towns and cities – resilience to climatic changes, improving mental and physical health and well-being, improving air quality through pollution filtration, reducing surface flooding, providing urban cooling, increasing property values and improving biodiversity.
All these benefits are lost if trees are not effectively established, and the more mature trees get, the greater the benefits and ecosystem services they provide.
Trees for Cities’ Track Record of Tree Establishment
Trees for Cities has an outstanding and consistent record of tree establishment. Over the last two years, we have average >95% establishment rates for our standard trees and 79% for our whips (young trees), which is well above the sector average. We are particularly proud of this achievement over the hottest summers on record, with extreme high temperatures and drought.
Critical Success Factors for Tree Establishment
Through over 30 years of practicing urban forestry, we have captured the critical success factors of good planting practice to ensure that trees establish and thrive.
Start before you plant
Good planting practice starts with selecting the right tree for the right place, sourcing trees from reputable suppliers (including from nurseries accredited through Plant Health Alliance). Trees in urban areas are often expected to grow in challenging soils, so soils may need to be improved or de-compacted, with competing vegetation removed before planting.
Species Selection
Due to climatic changes and the urban heat island effect, we find that many native British tree species are increasingly struggling to withstand the higher temperatures and drought conditions. It is important to select tree species that can tolerate harsher urban conditions whilst also considering potential further climatic changes in the future.
At Trees for Cities, we often select species that you would find growing around the Mediterranean basin, which, due to their relative geographical proximity to the UK and similar habitats that we have here and other parts of western & northern Europe, are also more likely to provide benefits to wildlife as well.
We do also select other species from around the world that are known to be reliable and tolerant of these changing conditions, which we also choose for their ornamental and amenity value. However, where possible, we do specify native species that are more adaptable to the drought conditions we are increasingly facing, particularly for our woodland creation projects.
Growth supplements
We sometimes add natural supplements/organic soil additives such as biochar, nettle tea or compost to tree pits or mixed in with water after planting to give trees a boost. We do this based on soil sample/test pit results and tree health monitoring on an as-needed basis rather than as standard.
Mulch
Our urban forest team refers to mulch as ‘brown gold’! Mulch can be any organic material such as wood chips, leaves or compost. Adding mulch as a protective layer on top of the soil around the newly planted tree is a vital element of our tree planting practice to support establishment. We are big fans of wood chip mulch.
Why is mulch so important?
- Mulch insulates the soil, helping to provide a buffer for the roots from hot & cold extremes
- Mulch retains water, helping to keep the roots moist
- Mulch keeps weeds out to help prevent root competition
- Mulch rots down and feeds the soil
- Mulch can even help reduce lawn mower & strimmer damage
Some key things we’ve learnt when it comes to mulch:
- The more the merrier – we lay down a nice thick layer of mulch, ideally between 50-100mm, as this really makes a big difference to a tree’s establishment
- Re-applying mulch matters – we top up mulch regularly as it degrades, especially during the summer months, as we find this is key to really helping trees to establish.
Watering
We water all our standard trees regularly during the spring and summer months for 3 years after planting. Trees in their first year of establishment are the most vulnerable, and so these trees get watered weekly. Trees in their second year of establishment get watered every 2 weeks, and trees in their third year of establishment get watered every 3-4 weeks. We also monitor all our trees’ health throughout the growing season and can increase watering for trees that are struggling as needed.
General aftercare
As well as watering and topping up mulch, we also weed around the base of our trees to reduce the competition for water and nutrients, as this makes a big difference when helping trees to establish. For our standard trees, we will also do any maintenance needed to repair broken straps, stakes or cages to reduce the potential for damage to the trees. Because all our trees are being monitored regularly, we are ready and able to give them any extra support they may need to establish well.
Community Engagement
When planting in public urban spaces, it is vital to engage local people when we plant and care for trees. Research has shown that community stewardship increases the chances of tree survival. Newly planted trees are particularly vulnerable – ownership can be achieved when communities are involved in the process of tree planting from start to finish (Jack-Scott et al., 2013).
Trees for Cities empowers people to plant and care for trees themselves, but communities often need technical advice, guidance and support to plant the right trees in the right places, plant them in the right way, and care for them properly.
Local authorities are also struggling with a lack of capacity and low budgets, so building community capacity offers a vital volunteer workforce, particularly to care for trees during periods of drought or to plant trees.
Monitoring Tree Health
Standard trees
We monitor the health of all our standard trees every time we visit them for watering. We record the health status of each individual tree at each visit, allowing us to increase our maintenance if needed, as well as track the progress of all our trees. If any trees are recorded as dead within the first year of establishment, we will replace them in the following planting season.
At the end of our 3 years of establishment, we can see what percentage of our standard trees have established well, as well as any that may be struggling and need additional care beyond the 3 years. This is all the information we share with our partners when we hand the trees back. Our target for standard tree establishment is 95%.
Woodlands
We conduct woodland establishment surveys 3 times over the summer growing season following planting. We use quadrat surveys to sample the health of trees within a given area, whereby we record the health status of each individual tree within the quadrat.
The surveys earlier in the growing season allow us to track the progress of the woodland establishment and adjust our maintenance if needed. The final survey at the end of the growing season allows us to see what percentage of the woodland trees have established. If we have an establishment rate below 80%, we will re-stock the woodland in the following planting season. Our target for woodland establishment is 85%.
Challenges of Tree Establishment in Urban Areas
Lack of funding for tree establishment and maintenance
Many funders want to fund tree planting, but not the essential establishment and maintenance work that is required to ensure that trees thrive to deliver vital ecosystem services. We are creating a Tree Care package to incentivise funders to support this important aspect of our work.
Urban Heat Island Effect
Urban spaces comprise multiple hard surfaces such as roads, footpaths, roofscapes, paved open spaces and gardens, etc, that store heat and contribute to the creation of an “urban heat island”. This occurs when land heats up quickly and stores that heat, which continues to radiate long after sunset.
In comparison to urban areas with plentiful tree cover and green spaces, areas devoid of trees may experience differences in local temperatures of between 5-7°C. This means urban trees face greater challenges of heat stress (i.e. leaf scorch) and a lack of water (the warmer it is, the more a tree transpires/loses water, and so the more water it needs to maintain all of its physiological processes, such as photosynthesis). This, combined with lower rainfall in our ever-warming summers and a high concentration of paved, or non-porous surfaces, means urban trees can really struggle to get enough water to establish well.
Trees in a Changing Climate
Urban spaces face growing threats from the impact of extreme weather events, due in part to dense building developments, sealed and paved surfaces, reduced vegetation cover, and limited absorbent landscapes.
Weather conditions during and between growing season are becoming more unpredictable – mild, wet summers tend to have few failures, but hot, dry summers/periods of drought can result in more failures of recently planted trees. In response to the increasing frequency of extreme temperatures, Trees for Cities has recently adjusted our maintenance programme as follows:
- Standard tree watering - more frequent watering over the summer, complemented by a public summer campaign to encourage residents to water young street trees #WateringWednesday
- Whip planting – reviewed our planting specification to help the trees prepare for harsh conditions, e.g. limit whip planting to Nov-Feb, mulch well and weed/mulch during the summer to give them the best chance to survive a tough summer.
- Species selection - climate resilient species, which often means a move away from native species in our standard planting. We still plant almost exclusively native for woodlands, however.
Woodland establishment
Watering a newly planted urban woodland poses logistical challenges. We advise planting earlier in the season (Nov – Feb), increasing mulch levels and re-mulching frequently over the summer, hand-weeding around the base of whips (although this relies on large-scale mobilisation of volunteers). Further work includes reviewing the type of tree stock, how trees are stored/handled before planting, and ground prep prior to planting.
Planting Policies and Networks
All tree planting and establishment is done in accordance with BS8545. All tree stock is secured through Plant Healthy suppliers and in line with our Biosecurity Policy. We carry out detailed site surveys prior to planting and use resources from the Trees & Design Action Group (TDAG) to ensure we are up to date with the latest practice.
How can I help care for trees in my neighbourhood?
-
Trees for Streets
Our street tree sponsorship scheme enables residents and businesses to green their communities, bringing the benefits of trees to where they live.
-
Stay informed
Subscribe to our monthly newsletter, Tree Times, and stay in the loop with our latest news, events, and fundraising opportunities.
-
Volunteer
People like you can help make our cities greener. Find out how to volunteer with us here.
Donate to Trees for Cities and together we can help cities grow into greener, cleaner and healthier places for people to live and work worldwide.
Donate